
Written
By: Stacey Sprain,
Certified Ambassador Loan Processor (CALP)
As a
person in the Mortgage Industry who works in a position that involves business
and credit analysis and writing credit policies to protect the interests of the
company, one particular article got my attention this week when it crossed my
desk. It was an article released in
Market
Watch, part of the Wall Street Journal digital network. The article stated
that HUD issued subpoenas to 15 mortgage companies on Tuesday in regards to
higher-than-average default rates on FHA loans and an overabundance of mortgage
insurance claims.
When I took a looked through the list I immediately
recognized a number of pretty big players; mortgage brokers we have all likely
dealt with at some point in our mortgage careers for one reason or another. But
I can’t say I’m surprised to see a couple of them. I clearly recall that they
were accepting what I considered “bottom of the barrel” FHA borrowers back in
2006 and 2007 before the market started its downward spiral due to foreclosures
and market declines. In fact, I see two of them that I know flat out drug their
feet implementing minimum credit score requirements in order to corner the
market while other FHA lenders starting cracking down on their own qualifying
requirements in anticipation of what was to come.
What always bothers me
most when I see these things is the lack or moral judgment and integrity that
was used by all of those involved. The unfortunate result of so many bad
decisions made by bad companies is that the good companies are now subject to
the consequences of the bad. One of our originators made a statement this week I
found humorous though very valid. He said “I feel like things have gotten so out
of control we can’t even get loans done anymore. I mean, what more documentation
can I request from my borrowers short of them providing a sample of their DNA?”
It’s unfortunate that so many of us have begun to feel this way.
I am
still outraged that those responsible for the sub-prime market crisis aren’t
rotting in prison somewhere. It still blows my mind to think that anyone in
their right mind could sleep at night knowing they’d just agreed to grant a
$200000 mortgage to borrowers with credit scores in the 400s, unstable
employment and no verified history of housing expense. And it’s not just the
lending part that concerns me but more importantly, the burden of knowing you’d
put such borrowers in that position having to realize full well that they were
headed toward disaster. They were guaranteed to fail but somebody lent them the
money anyway. It doesn’t get more wrong than that.
So, what kinds of
things can we all do to make sure our companies don’t end up being investigated
for higher-than-average default rates? It’s really as simple as diverting back
to the days of full loan documentation requirements in partnership with
utilization of modern tools and technologies.
Even if your lenders
aren’t requiring tax transcripts for underwriting, most companies are pulling
them pre-purchase or post purchase so you may as well simply obtain them for all
of your loan files and make sure qualifying income is tight and right from the
beginning. Transcripts can be used as a great resource for more than just income
verification. They can also be used to validate identity, occupancy and marital
status. Transcripts validate most importantly that the person listed on your
loan application filed taxes under the social security number and residence
address listed on the loan application.
They also verify whether or not
the returns were filed on time. Transcripts also confirm whether each borrower
filed individually or jointly and will confirm the number of dependents so you
can compare with loan application data. In addition, transcripts may verify
undisclosed businesses potentially uncovering business losses that can
negatively affect future financial stability and the borrower’s ability to make
timely mortgage payments. In my opinion, any company that hasn’t incorporated
transcript requirements into originating and underwriting procedures is a
“sitting duck” for potential fraud and early defaults.
Transcripts have
become much less expensive in recent months also. A year ago we may have been
paying $20 and more for two years but with the IRS lowering their processing fee
by $4 effective October 1, 2009, many companies became more cost-friendly. Now
obtaining two years transcripts can cost as little as $15 and even lower for
those companies that have the luxury of offering volume discount rates.
Other tools to be taken advantage of in today’s market are the fraud
detection tools and services offered by credit bureaus and third party vendors
like First American CoreLogic and Interthinx. Most credit vendors now have the
ability to offer a full suite of fraud detection and risk analysis options that
are available right as you pull your standard credit reports. These services
have the ability to analyze a minimum data set in order to render risk scoring
based on data combinations and public record searches. Vendors like CoreLogic
and Interthinx take risk analysis even further by evaluation all of the loan
parties as well as the property in order to render a full report that analyzes
the overall loan risk by category to give red flags of potential loan fraud.
Tools like this are invaluable in today’s world.
When researching vendor
options for things like transcripts and fraud detection services, be sure to ask
questions about volume discounts, support resources, systems integration and
training abilities.
The sooner you implement tools and resources like
those I’ve mentioned above, the less likely your company will be to end up
subpoenaed by HUD for excessive defaults and claims like these lenders did:
- First Tennessee Bank N.A., Memphis, Tenn.
- Alethes LLC, Lakeway,
Texas
- Security Atlantic Mortgage Co., Edison, N.J.
- Pine State
Mortgage Corporation, Atlanta.
- Birmingham Bancorp Mortgage Corporation,
West Bloomfield, Mich.
- Alacrity Financial Services, LLC, Southlake, Texas
- Assurity Financial Services, LLC, Englewood, Colo.
- D and R Mortgage
Corporation, Farmington, Mich.
- Webster Bank, Cheshire, Conn.
-
Mac-Clair Mortgage Corporation, Flint, Mich.
- Americare Investment Group,
Inc., Arlington, Texas
- 1st Advantage Mortgage, Lombard, Ill.
-
American Sterling Bank, Independence, Mo.
- Sterling National Mortgage
Company Inc., Great Neck, N.Y.
- Dell Franklin Financial LLC, Columbia, Md.
About the Writer. As one of NAMP's volunteer writers,
Stacey Sprain is currently a NAMP member in good standing and is a NAMP
Certified Ambassador Loan Processor (CALP). If you would like to become a
volunteer writer for NAMP, please email us at:
blog@mortgageprocessor.org.